Customer reviews can influence whether someone chooses your business, but not every review platform supports your online visibility in the same way.
You may already collect testimonials through ServiceM8, display reviews through Trustindex or receive recommendations on Facebook and LinkedIn. These reviews are valuable, but are they as useful for SEO as reviews left directly on Google?
The short answer is no. If your main goal is improving your visibility in local Google searches, Google reviews should be the priority. Reviews collected elsewhere still have an important role because they strengthen trust and can help turn website visitors into enquiries.
The strongest approach is to use both.
Why Google reviews matter for local SEO
Google reviews are connected directly to your Google Business Profile and appear across Google Search and Google Maps.
Google explains that local search results are mainly based on relevance, distance and prominence. The number of reviews a business has, along with positive ratings, can contribute to prominence and may help its local ranking.
This is particularly important when someone searches for a local service, such as:
- plumber near me
- electrician Gold Coast
- local landscaper
- website designer Gold Coast
- air conditioning repairs near me
A strong Google review profile can help your business stand out before someone reaches your website. The star rating, number of reviews and recent customer experiences are all visible at an important point in the decision making process.
Positive reviews and helpful business replies can also build confidence and encourage people to visit your website, call or request a quote.
Reviews are not the only part of local SEO. Your website content, Google Business Profile information, location relevance, links and wider online presence also matter. However, Google reviews are a valuable signal that should not be overlooked.
What about reviews from ServiceM8, Trustindex, Facebook and LinkedIn?
Reviews and testimonials from other platforms still provide real value. They simply do a different job.
ServiceM8 testimonials
ServiceM8 can help service businesses request customer feedback as part of the job follow up process. These testimonials can provide specific insights into reliability, communication, workmanship and the overall customer experience.
They can be particularly effective on service pages, project pages and beside enquiry forms. However, they do not add to the review count or star rating on your Google Business Profile.
Trustindex and review widgets
Trustindex and similar tools can display reviews from one or more platforms on your website. This can make it easier to keep review content current and show visitors that feedback has come from a recognisable external source.
These widgets are useful for trust and convenience. However, displaying reviews through a widget does not mean those reviews will improve your Google Business Profile ranking. Some widgets may also load content in a way that search engines cannot easily read, so their biggest benefit is often conversion rather than SEO.
The widget should also be checked on mobile and for page speed. A heavy review feed can slow a page down or take up too much space, which may work against the customer experience.
Facebook reviews and recommendations
Facebook recommendations can show that your business is active and trusted within its community. They may be helpful when potential customers research your business on social media or see your page through a recommendation.
They can support your overall reputation, but they do not increase your Google review count. A positive Facebook presence may help people feel comfortable choosing you, although the reviews themselves do not provide the same local SEO value as reviews left on Google.
LinkedIn recommendations
LinkedIn recommendations are especially useful for consultants, coaches, professional service providers and business to business companies. They can demonstrate expertise, working relationships and professional outcomes.
These recommendations support credibility on LinkedIn and can be repurposed on your website with permission. They are not connected to your Google Business Profile, so they should be treated as professional proof rather than a direct local SEO tool.
Do testimonials on your website help SEO?
Website testimonials can support SEO indirectly when they add useful, original and relevant information to a page.
A detailed review might naturally mention:
- the service completed
- the customer’s problem
- the suburb or service area
- the result achieved
- the quality of the experience
This context can make a page more helpful to visitors and give search engines a clearer picture of the services your business provides.
Testimonials can also improve trust and encourage more people to make an enquiry. That conversion benefit matters even when the review itself is not directly improving rankings.
Keep testimonials genuine. Do not insert keywords into a customer’s comments or change the meaning of what they said. You should also have permission before publishing someone’s name, business or other identifying information.
Will review schema give my website stars in Google?
Adding review schema does not guarantee that stars will appear beside your website in search results.
Google generally does not show review rich results when a business marks up reviews about itself on its own website. This includes reviews displayed through a third party widget when the business controls where those reviews appear.
Review widgets can still be useful for visitors. They just should not be installed with the expectation that they will automatically add star ratings to your website’s organic Google listing.
Which review platform should you prioritise?
If your main goal is local SEO and increased visibility across Google Search and Maps, prioritise Google reviews.
If your main goal is strengthening the website and helping potential customers feel confident enough to enquire, use selected testimonials from ServiceM8, Facebook, LinkedIn or another trusted platform.
The platforms serve different purposes:
| Review source | Main value | Directly increases Google review count? |
|---|---|---|
| Google reviews | Local visibility, trust in Search and Maps | Yes |
| ServiceM8 testimonials | Service specific trust and customer feedback | No |
| Trustindex or review widgets | Displays external reviews conveniently on your website | No |
| Facebook recommendations | Social proof and community credibility | No |
| LinkedIn recommendations | Professional credibility and business to business trust | No |
The best review strategy for a service business
Rather than sending every customer to several platforms, create a simple and consistent process.
- Make Google your primary public review platform.
- Send customers a direct Google review link after the job or project is complete.
- Use selected testimonials from ServiceM8, Facebook or LinkedIn on relevant website pages.
- Link to the original review source where appropriate so visitors can verify the feedback.
- Reply to Google reviews professionally and helpfully.
- Request reviews consistently instead of collecting many at once and then stopping.
- Monitor every platform you actively promote so customer feedback is not left unanswered.
Do not offer rewards in exchange for positive Google reviews. Your request should be for honest feedback, and your review process should not filter customers based on whether you expect a positive or negative response.
Where should reviews appear on your website?
Do not hide every testimonial on one reviews page. A dedicated page can be useful, but your strongest reviews should also appear where customers are making decisions.
Consider placing reviews on:
- the homepage
- individual service pages
- location pages
- project and case study pages
- quote and contact pages
- beside important calls to action
Match the review to the content whenever possible. A testimonial about emergency plumbing belongs on the emergency plumbing page. A LinkedIn recommendation about strategic consulting will be more persuasive on the relevant consulting service page.
The closer the testimonial is to the service or concern it supports, the more useful it is to the potential customer.
Should you collect reviews on more than one platform?
You can, but avoid making the process complicated for customers and clients.
Choose one main platform based on your goals. For most local service businesses, this should be Google. Other platforms can collect feedback naturally through your existing systems and customer relationships.
For example, you might request a Google review after completing a project, collect service feedback through ServiceM8 and receive occasional recommendations through Facebook or LinkedIn. With permission, the most relevant comments can then be featured across your website.
This gives you visibility on Google and strong trust content throughout the customer journey.
The final verdict
Google reviews are generally the best choice for local SEO because they contribute to the public review signals connected to your Google Business Profile.
Reviews from ServiceM8, Trustindex, Facebook, LinkedIn and other platforms are still valuable. They strengthen your reputation, provide useful social proof and help website visitors feel more confident about taking the next step.
Use Google reviews to support visibility in search. Use testimonials from other platforms to reinforce trust once someone reaches your website.
If your business has plenty of positive feedback but it is not placed where customers need reassurance, a strategic website review can identify where testimonials, trust signals and calls to action could work harder.
Share a few details about your website and we will be in touch to talk through the options, process and next steps.
Sources
-
Google Business Profile Help: https://support.google.com/business/answer/7091
-
Google Search Central review snippet guidelines: https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/structured-data/review-snippet
